Lodging studies

We sledded White Sands and the snow above Cloudcroft. Then I checked 47 lodging websites around it.

By Joshua Downey, GM of Comal Inn · November 16, 2026 · 7 min read

The short answer

We camped in the snow above Cloudcroft, New Mexico, and sledded the dunes at White Sands. Then I ran 47 independent places to stay around Cloudcroft and Ruidoso through the same free website check this site offers. Cloudcroft's websites were faster. Ruidoso's were easier to book. The median phone score was 67 out of 100, the best of any study so far, but only 4 sites scored 90 or higher, and two Ruidoso-area homepages weighed more than 40 MB. Only 10 of 43 homepages tell Google they're a place to stay.

Our trip

We went to the Cloudcroft area in March with our small off-road trailer and a couple of sledding discs. It was a huge snow year in the Sacramento Mountains. When we stopped at the ranger district office, the ranger was surprised we planned to camp out in the forest at all. Most of the forest roads were buried, and unless you had a snowmobile, there weren't many places left to camp. She laughed about it, then warned us a big storm was coming in two days. We already knew. We were packed up and gone before it hit.

The discs got a workout, on the white gypsum dunes at White Sands National Park and for days in the snow above Cloudcroft. The sledding, the camp and an icy hike are at the end, after the numbers.

One conversation stuck with me. We had the sledding hill to ourselves most days, until a family showed up with kids the same age as ours. They were staying in Ruidoso and said it was packed. If they'd known how quiet Cloudcroft was, they said, they would have planned their whole trip here. So this study is split the same way, Cloudcroft and the towns around it on one side, Ruidoso and its neighbors on the other.

Two mountain towns

Cloudcroft sits at 8,676 feet in the Sacramento Mountains, surrounded by the Lincoln National Forest. About 750 people lived there at the 2020 census. It started as a railroad resort. The railroad climbed the mountain to haul timber out, and the first resort, The Pavilion, opened in 1899. The Mexican Canyon Trestle, built the same year, still stands just west of town. Ski Cloudcroft is a small family ski hill that the Forest Service calls one of the southernmost ski areas in the U.S.

Ruidoso is the bigger town, with about 7,700 people at the 2020 census, on the northern edge of the same mountains. Ski Apache is about 15 miles away. The Mescalero Apache Tribe has owned and run it since 1963, and it tops out at 11,500 feet. North of Ruidoso, Capitan has Smokey Bear Historical Park, and Lincoln, the center of the Lincoln County War, is now a state historic site.

The two towns are joined by NM 244, about 29 miles of mountain road from Cloudcroft through the forest and the Mescalero Apache Reservation to US 70. Down off the mountain to the west is the Tularosa Basin and White Sands National Park, which the National Park Service calls the world's largest gypsum dunefield.

A yucca with a tall dried flower stalk growing out of rippled white gypsum sand at White Sands National Park, with its shadow on the sand and a blue sky streaked with clouds
A yucca in the gypsum dunes at White Sands National Park.

Map

Cloudcroft, Ruidoso and the towns around them

SACRAMENTOMOUNTAINSTULAROSABASINCloudcroftMayhillRuidosoRuidoso DownsAltoLincolnAlamogordoTularosaMescaleroWhite Sands National ParkSki ApacheCapitanOsha Trail

Lodging in this study, not namedTrailheadSightHighway

NM 244 links Cloudcroft and Ruidoso through the Mescalero Apache Reservation. Simplified map, not for navigation.

The short version

Median phone speed score, out of 100
67Median phone speed score, out of 100
Scored 90 or higher, Google’s “good”
4 of 46Scored 90 or higher, Google’s “good”
Median time to show the main content
10.0 secMedian time to show the main content
Homepages that tell Google they’re lodging
10 of 43Homepages that tell Google they’re lodging
47 independent lodging websites around Cloudcroft and Ruidoso, checked on a simulated phone

It's a small study, so I'm giving counts instead of percentages. The median phone score was the best of the five areas I've checked. The rest looks familiar. Most homepages are slow to show their main content, a third have no Book button, and very few tell Google or AI tools what they are.

Cloudcroft vs. Ruidoso

Lodging websites on the Cloudcroft side compared with the Ruidoso side
MeasureCloudcroft sideRuidoso side
Median phone speed score6866
Scored 90 or higher1 of 163 of 30
Median time to show the main content6.1 sec11.5 sec
Took more than 10 seconds5 of 1618 of 30
Median homepage weight2.7 MB3.2 MB
No Book link on the homepage7 of 137 of 30
Tell Google they’re lodging3 of 137 of 30
Cloudcroft side: 16 in Cloudcroft and Mayhill. Ruidoso side: 31 in Ruidoso, Ruidoso Downs, Alto and Lincoln

The family at the sledding hill was right about the towns, and the websites split the same way. Ruidoso has about twice as many independent places to stay with their own website. Cloudcroft's were faster. The median scores were close, but on the Cloudcroft side the main content showed up in 6.1 seconds, against 11.5 on the Ruidoso side, and only 5 of 16 took more than 10 seconds.

Ruidoso's sites were easier to book. 7 of 13 Cloudcroft-side homepages had no Book link at all, against 7 of 30 in Ruidoso. Around Cloudcroft, a lot of the cabins in the town's own directories have no website of their own, and several sites listed there no longer load. Searching for a place to stay turns up mostly Airbnb and Vrbo. A quiet town with few good websites is an opening for anyone who builds one.

Speed on a phone

Phone speed scores, 46 lodging websites

How many sites landed in each range. 90 and up is good.

0102030405060708090

Poor, under 50 (7 sites)Needs work, 50 to 89 (35 sites)Good, 90 and up (4 sites)

Google PageSpeed Insights mobile score, one test per homepage

The median phone score was 67, a few points ahead of Big Bend and the Buffalo River. 7 of 46 scored under 50, and 4 reached 90 or higher.

Google wants the main content on screen within 2.5 seconds, and only 2 sites made it. The median was 10 seconds, and 23 of 46 took longer than that.

How heavy the homepages are

Homepage weight, 46 lodging websites

Everything a phone downloads to show the homepage.

2 MB or less
16 of 46 sites
2 to 5 MB
15 of 46 sites
5 to 10 MB
10 of 46 sites
Over 10 MB
5 of 46 sites

The median homepage weighed 3.0 MB, and 16 came in at 2 MB or less. Then there were two on the Ruidoso side that weighed 52.3 MB and 42.6 MB. The heavier one took 55 seconds to show its main content on a simulated phone. Both are well past the 32.2 MB homepage in Marfa that was the heaviest in the Big Bend study.

In the mountains, a guest may be checking from a pull-off with weak service. My note on why a vacation rental website loads slow shows how to lighten a homepage without losing the view.

Where the Book buttons go

Where the Book links on 43 homepages went

Each property counted once, by its worst link.

Every Book link went to a booking page or their own site
26
A Book link just reloaded the homepage
1
A Book link sent guests to Airbnb or Vrbo
2
No Book link found on the homepage
14
The check follows every Book, Reserve and Availability link on the homepage

Of the 29 homepages with Book links, 26 sent every one to a booking page or a page on their own site. The check flagged three links as going nowhere, and I tapped each one by hand. Two jump to an availability form further down the page and one jumps to a reservations section, so they work. One more site's Book Now button just reloads the homepage.

Two sent guests from their own website to Vrbo or Airbnb. A guest who already found your site is the last person you want to hand back to a listing site, where other rentals are one tap away.

The bigger gap was the 14 homepages with no Book link at all. Some are property managers who list rentals on inside pages, and some take bookings by phone. Either way, a guest on a phone has to dig, or call, to find out if you're open on their dates.

Phone, email and what Google reads

What the homepage gives guests and Google

43 homepages the check could read.

Page title and description set
32 of 43 sites
Tap-to-call phone number
29 of 43 sites
Email link
19 of 43 sites
Lodging details for Google and AI tools
10 of 43 sites

29 of 43 had a tap-to-call phone number and 19 had an email link, but 12 had neither, so a guest on a phone had no one-tap way to reach them. Only 5 had a phone link, an email link and lodging details all together. 11 didn't set both a page title and a description.

Just 10 of 43 homepages had the small piece of structured data that tells Google and AI tools this is a place to stay. When someone asks ChatGPT for a quiet cabin near Cloudcroft, those few lines of code are the difference between being understood and being guessed at.

Compared with the other studies

This is the fifth study in the series, after 97 Hill Country lodging websites, 31 around Fiery Gizzard, 41 around the Buffalo River and 48 around Big Bend. Cloudcroft and Ruidoso had the best median phone score so far, and also the two heaviest homepages. The code that tells Google what you are is still missing almost everywhere.

See every study side by side.

What to do with this

If you run a cabin, lodge, motel or RV park in the Sacramento Mountains, start here:

  1. Have a website of your own. Around Cloudcroft especially, most places to stay only show up on listing sites. Your own site is the one place a guest can find you without a dozen other cabins next to you.
  2. Put a Book button on the homepage. Make it go to your own booking page, not to Airbnb or Vrbo.
  3. Size your photos for a phone. A homepage over 10 MB is a long wait on one bar of service.
  4. Tell Google what you are. Add lodging details to your page code. Only 10 of 43 sites here did.
  5. Answer the snow questions. Is the road to your place plowed, do guests need four-wheel drive or chains, how far is it to the sledding hills and the ski areas, and what happens to a booking when a storm closes the road. Those are the questions guests and AI tools are asking every winter.

Sledding, a snowy hike and camp

We sledded several days at the Upper Karr Recreation Area, in the forest near Cloudcroft. Most of the time we had the hill to ourselves. That's where we met the family from Ruidoso.

A family of four on a snowy sledding hill at the Upper Karr Recreation Area near Cloudcroft, New Mexico, with green sledding discs, bare aspens and evergreens under a blue sky
Our sledding hill at the Upper Karr Recreation Area, near Cloudcroft.

The same discs went down the dunes at White Sands. The National Park Service says waxed plastic snow saucers work best, and you can buy them at the park's gift shop or bring your own. Pick a dune with a gentle slope and a flat run-out, and keep away from the boardwalk and the road. Gypsum sand and mountain snow in the same trip is hard to beat.

Two people carrying green sledding discs up the crest of a tall white gypsum dune at White Sands National Park under a deep blue sky
Hauling the discs back up a dune at White Sands.

We camped two nights off Upper Rio Peñasco Road. We only made it about a mile down the road, to where Water Canyon Road comes in. Past that, Rio Peñasco was covered in snow, and Water Canyon Road was wet and sloppy, so we set up camp right there. We were above 9,000 feet, and it got down into the single digits at night.

A white Jeep and a small off-road camper trailer with a rooftop tent and awning, set up among tall evergreens at a dispersed campsite off Upper Rio Peñasco Road, with patches of snow on the ground
Our camp off Upper Rio Peñasco Road, where Water Canyon Road comes in.

The Osha Trail starts just west of Cloudcroft, off US 82, and loops through the forest with views out over the Tularosa Basin toward White Sands. The front of the loop was clear. The back side was in full shade, and for about half a mile it was solid ice. We didn't have crampons, and it was about as slippery as hiking gets. If you go in winter, bring traction.

GPS track of the Osha Trail loop from the trailhead off US 82 just west of Cloudcroft, New Mexico, near the Mexican Canyon Railroad Trestle
Distance
2.53 miDistance
Time
1:45Time
Climbing
448 ftClimbing
The Osha Trail loop from US 82, just west of Cloudcroft

How I did it

Which properties. I started with the lodging listings from the Cloudcroft Chamber of Commerce, the Discover Ruidoso and Visit Ruidoso directories and the Ruidoso Valley Chamber of Commerce. Then I ran Google searches for cabins, lodges, motels, RV parks and vacation rentals in Cloudcroft and Ruidoso. I kept independent properties with their own website: 16 on the Cloudcroft side, in Cloudcroft and Mayhill, and 31 on the Ruidoso side, in Ruidoso, Ruidoso Downs, Alto and Lincoln. I left out Airbnb- and Vrbo-only listings, booking and listing sites, chains, two large resorts, one hotel that's part of a multi-property group, one site that now belongs to a different business, and sites that were down or couldn't be reached when I checked.

What I checked. Each homepage went through the Firsthand Stays website check on November 9, 2026. It runs Google PageSpeed Insights on a simulated phone, then reads the homepage like a phone browser would, and follows each Book, Reserve and Availability link to see where it leads. When Google's speed test didn't finish, I ran it again, then ran it directly in PageSpeed Insights. I tapped Book buttons by hand where the check couldn't follow them.

The limits. It's a small sample, so a few sites can move the numbers. Scores also move a few points between runs. Two homepages turn away automated visitors and one never answered, so they have a speed score but couldn't be read. One lodge's homepage only shows a bot check, so it has no score, and totals use 46 sites for speed and 43 for everything else. It only looks at the homepage. As in the earlier studies, I didn't count llms.txt files, because many website builders now add one automatically. None of the properties are named.

Quick answers

Is it better to stay in Cloudcroft or Ruidoso?

It depends on the trip. Ruidoso is the bigger town, with more restaurants, shops and Ski Apache close by, and more places to stay. Cloudcroft is smaller and quieter, at 8,676 feet in the Lincoln National Forest, with trails and snow play close by and White Sands National Park down the mountain. NM 244 connects them, about 29 miles of mountain road from Cloudcroft to US 70 and then on into Ruidoso, so it’s easy to visit one from the other.

How far is Cloudcroft from White Sands National Park?

Cloudcroft sits right above Alamogordo on US 82, and the White Sands visitor center is about 15 miles west of Alamogordo, per the National Park Service. It’s an easy day trip down the mountain, with a big change in weather between the two.

Can you sled at White Sands?

Yes. The National Park Service says waxed plastic snow saucers work best, and you can buy them at the park’s gift shop or bring your own. Pick a dune with a gentle slope and a flat run-out, sit or lie with your feet downhill, and stay away from the boardwalk area and the road.

Where is the Osha Trail?

The Osha Trail (T10) starts just west of Cloudcroft, where US 82 meets Muchachita Street, in the Lincoln National Forest. The Forest Service lists it at 2.1 miles, with views over the Tularosa Basin and White Sands.

How do lodging websites around Cloudcroft and Ruidoso do on a phone?

In my check of 47 independent places to stay, the median phone speed score was 67 out of 100, the best of any area I’ve studied so far, but only 4 sites scored 90 or higher. The median homepage took 10 seconds to show its main content on a simulated phone. Cloudcroft’s sites were faster, at 6.1 seconds, while Ruidoso’s were more likely to have a Book button on the homepage.

Want me to look at your site?

Send me your website. I'll tell you what I'd fix first, for free.